A few weeks ago I received a pleading letter from the Charles River Museum of Industry.
(Picture from here.)
The CRMI is a small museum in downtown Waltham—a place people might know by the old Waltham watches built by the Waltham Watch Company. Massachusetts was a hotbed of industrial production and innovation during the 19th and 20th centuries. In the 19th century it was manufacturing or precision instruments, textiles, shoes—pretty much everything. The US was worried that Britain would have a stranglehold on manufacturing forever. First the Embargo Act of 1807 forbidding imports from Britain and then the War of 1812 forced America into the industrial revolution.
This is what the CRMI is all about: charting how the US (as shown in Massachusetts) navigated this period. The Museum has example machinery, some of the Waltham Watch Company’s original precision tool and dies, example looms. Every year it has a Model Engineering show put on by the New England Model Engineering Society where steam engines, Stirling engines, pulse rocket devices—all manner of precision-built machines shown both full size and in miniature. It’s a cacophony of hisses, thumps, and bangs showing the chops of 19th century engineers.
I’ve been going for years.
The message from the Museum was regarding yet another destructive executive order. This one to defund and destroy the Institute of Museum and Library Services. That order is here.
The IMLS budget is under 300 million dollars—.003% of the federal budget. You can see it here. About three quarters of its money is block grants to the states for library support. A little goes towards research. Nine percent goes to general museums. About seven percent goes museums for Latino, African Americans, Native Americans, and Native Hawaiians. Seventy employees distribute these funds.
Three million goes to support libraries in Tennessee. Three quarters of a million went to libraries in Nebraska. Half a million went to support a program in the Children’s Museum of Kansas City. A hundred-fifty thousand went to a children’s museum program in Montana. Along with the Council of American Jewish Museums, the IMLS supported creating resources to help fight against anti-semitism.
Libraries and museums. If we’re going to put money anywhere—if there is a common good to be supported by our common tax revenue—why shouldn’t that be libraries and museums. (Or cancer research. Or heart disease.)
We can’t afford libraries and museums but we can afford huge tax cuts for billionaires? We can’t afford cancer research but we can afford a bigger defense department?
I’ve worked in government departments both large and small. I’ve worked in corporations both large and small. Business doesn’t pursue opportunities where there’s no money. Critical problems that can’t be solved by private enterprise must be solved by government. That’s why public service exists.
I have seen civil servants do miraculous things with vanishingly small budgets. I have seen them help bring bird populations back where they were lost, nurture the innovation of amazing general aviation instrumentation, and enable me to bury my parents in Arlington National Cemetery. All with grace, honesty, attention to detail, and respect.
There may be civil servants out there that don’t do any work or take home two paychecks but I’ve never seen them. I have seen civil servants hobbled by bad legislation and worse leaders and then vilified for nothing more than doing the thankless job handed them by political government. Vilified for things that are completely out of their control.
This isn’t about efficiency or budget considerations or the deficit. If it were about efficiency, why take down social security one of the most efficient systems on the planet? If it were about budget considerations or the deficit, we wouldn’t be getting tax cuts or shutting down the IRS—what businessman cuts his own revenue stream? I’ll tell you: a businessman who can’t keep from going bankrupt. This isn’t about truth—truth is what you need to know whether you like it or not. This is about people fantasizing about an imaginary better time. This isn’t fixing the system. It’s breaking the system and then saying we have to scrap it because it doesn’t work—while transferring our money into the coffers of the ludicrously wealthy.
This is insane.
America used to be a shining beacon of innovation, science, and technology. That came largely from the investment the United States government—as allocated by Congress—made in United States institutions.
Not anymore.